Ben Chiarot Comparables

Ah the monetary and overall value of a player to a team. What a topic of discussion, isn’t it? You see, it’s a extremely subjective topic. We’ve all been in discussions with other people about a specific player and we’ve all disagreed with some of them about their take on a players’ worth. You see, while one may feel strongly about their opinion about a certain player, it doesn’t necessarily make them true. Oh it’s certainly true in their own mind and they’ll make sure to tell you so. But like any subjective topic, there’s more grey than there is black or white.

While it’s the same phenomenon across the NHL, we don’t have to look far in Montreal to find examples. People are still talking about a three year old trade of a defenseman who shall remain nameless for the purpose of this topic, but we know who we’re talking about, right? But we can’t blame fans for having a strong opinion about some players’ worth. Think about it… NHL General Managers disagree amongst each other about the value of certain players, killing more trade talks than we can begin to imagine. Further, those GMs are often in disagreement with players’ agents when it comes to contract talks. Here’s the only fact: everyone has a subjective opinion and the worth of a player to one team is, more often than not, not the same for the team next door.

One recent topic of discussion amongst Habs’ fans has been about the value of the team’s most recent Unrestricted Free Agent’s signing: Ben Chiarot. But before we get into this, here are some facts about the rugged Hamilton native:

Back on July 4th, Chiarot signed a 3-year, $10.5 million dollar deal with Montreal as a UFA. So far this season, he has played 14 games at the time of writing this. In those 14 games, he is averaging 20:43 minutes of ice time per game, third on the team behind only Jeff Petry and Shea Weber, who both play on the right side while Chiarot plays left. He has one goal, one assist and has a differential of plus -3. He’s second on the Habs in hits (34), 3rd in blocked shots (18) and he has 27 shots on goal, good for 8th on his team. He’s done all of that while getting accustomed to a new City, a new team, learning a new system and slowly developing chemistry with his defense partner(s) and teammates, getting to know their habits. Those are undeniable facts.

Contract comparables

You have people saying that Chiarot is overpaid, that he doesn’t always make the right decision with the puck, overcommits at times, gets caught out of position other times. While you certainly won’t find a topic of debate with yours truly when it comes to those assessments, I will certainly argue about his salary and his worth. You see, after some good discussions with other Habs’ fans on Twitter during the game in Dallas, I decided to do some research… because that’s what I do. I typically don’t just argue for the sake of arguing. I like to, as much as possible, back up my statements, my beliefs and my opinions. If I’m wrong after doing my research, I will certainly admit it too.

Let’s take a look at similar contracts around the NHL, contracts that Chiarot’s agent likely used to compare his client to, if he was doing his job (which I’m sure he was). I have added a couple of notes below the table to help you put some of those numbers into context.

Marc Staal28UFA5.768.2620157913
Niklas Hjalmarsson27UFA4.156.3820138210
Karl Alzner28UFA4.6356.17201791
Calvin De Haan27UFA4.5545.7220187414
Brendan Smith28UFA4.3545.820176313
Dmitry Kulikov26UFA4.3335.782017576
Ian Cole29UFA4.2535.3520187115
Kris Russell30UFA445.3320177216
Erik Gudbranson 26UFA435.3320187610
Jason Demers28UFA4.556.162016358
Justin Braun27UFA3.855.5120147816
Michael Stone27UFA3.534.672017145
Ben Chiarot28UFA3.534.2920197820
Patrik Nemeth27UFA3.023.6820197410
Carl Gunnarsson29UFA2.933.972016257
John Moore27UFA2.7553.4620186113
Thomas Hickey29UFA2.543.142018404
Jordie Benn31UFA2.022.4520198122

* Stats from


  1. Whether we agree with it or not, UFA’s players’ agents definitely use comparables when negotiating a client’s contract, which is why I’ve included last year’s stats and contract info.
  2. There is a premium to pay to get most UFA’s to sign in Canada, Montreal included. Keep that in mind as well, again whether we agree with it or not.

Some will argue that the team would have been better off re-signing 31 year old Jordie Benn. That’s a very defendable point but the team decided to go with a younger, more physical Chiarot who is at the very least, a slight improvement over Benn. Three years is a very good term as well, all things considered.

Ben Chiarot

So what’s the issue here? The most logical answer is that some people’s expectations are unrealistic. You pay a player $3.5M and they’re expecting near perfection. You know what? He is what he is: a fairly solid veteran who will play physical, be okay (no more) at moving the puck, will block shots and will, more often than not, be reliable in his own zone. But he will make mistakes, more so than a defenseman who’s amongst the tops in the league.

While he’s a very good player, Petry is known across the NHL for his brain cramps. He reminds me a lot of Alex Edler in Vancouver. Those players will be playing a great game but will make a couple of very bad decisions which ultimately, will result in a scoring chance or a goal. But Chiarot is making $2 million less than Petry, and that gap will be much bigger when he signs his new contract this upcoming summer, and we all know that.

All in all, the issue is not so much with Chiarot and his play, but rather with the somewhat unrealistic expectations some people have on him… at least in my opinion. The opinions will also vary depending on when the comments are made. This discussion took place during a game where the Canadiens were getting outplayed and outscored, bringing a ton of negativity in the fan base. Regardless, Chiarot is a $3.5M player and he’s worth every penny when comparing league-wide. Now let’s go back at enjoying the games and cheer on our favourite team, shall we? Go Habs Go!

Montreal? Why Not? Habs Struggling to Attract UFAs

Benjamin Franklin once said that there are two certainties in life: death and taxes. But if you ask anyone who has been the General Manager of the Montreal Canadiens, they will tell you that there’s a third one: many NHL players want nothing to do with playing in Montreal.

Since taking over the job in the summer of 2012, Marc Bergevin has had the unfortunate reality thrown in his face in a few occasions. Every summer, reputable hockey insiders report that Bergevin is in on pending Unrestricted Free Agent yet, it seems like they all sign elsewhere. Just last summer, the Canadiens’ GM had tons of money to throw at pending UFA John Tavares but the former Islanders’ captain didn’t even want to grant Montreal a meeting. If that’s not enough to discourage a GM, I don’t know what is. But in spite of the setbacks, Bergevin keeps plugging away at it. Eventually, one will say yes, right? Right?

Again this past summer, insiders said that Bergevin and the Canadiens were one of the final four teams being considered by the highly coveted centre Matt Duchene and we know what happened: he signed with the Nashville Predators. Bergevin had to resort to signing Sebastian Aho to an offer sheet, a topic which he discussed recently with Marc Denis on RDS.

But why would that be? We’re talking about the NHL’s oldest and most decorated franchise in history. No less than 24 times have captains of the Canadiens lifted the Stanley Cup over their head at the end of the playoffs. And yet in the annual players’ poll done by the NHLPA, the Bell Centre is always amongst the top as a place where players love to play and on quality of ice. Well folks, there are several factors it seems.


Here’s what is probably one of the biggest factors: Taxes. In order to compensate for the taxe aspect of the contract, the team often is having to overpay to get players to listen and even then, it’s no guarantee. Yet, they have the same salary cap, creating an uneven playing field.

Alexander Radulov chose the money.

For example, Alexander Radulov was offered the exact same contract by Bergevin and the Canadiens, hoping that the controversial Russian player would acknowledge that the previous year, they gave him a chance to get back to the NHL… to no avail. Based on the calculator on, the Habs would have had to pay Radulov around $8 million instead of the $6.25 million Dallas is paying him, in order for him to take home the same amount. That’s almost $2 million that the team couldn’t spend on other players and for what? Just to compensate for taxes! Yes, there are ways for players to write off some expenses but the same can be said in any other NHL City.

Until the NHL decides to have some sort of equalizer, it will stay the same. According to hockey experts and analysts, this is one of the major contributing factors as to why no Canadian team has won the Stanley Cup since the Habs did it in 1993.


How often have we heard players in Florida or in California saying that they love being able to get to the rink in shorts and t-shirts, or go to the beach after practice? You’re not going to do that in Montreal during hockey season! As a matter of fact, getting around in Montreal is a challenge in any season, but winters are particularly troublesome. Of the Canadian Cities, even Vancouver is better in that aspect than Montreal.


While there are many media outlets in all Canadian Cities, Montreal is known as having the most. There are often more media members at a Habs’ practice than there are in many other Cities’ games. While the sheer number can represent a problem for some UFAs, it’s the dramatization and constant negativity that draws the most attention with the players. The Réjean Tremblay, Michel Villeneuve and Brendan Kelly‘s of this world are the TMZ of Montreal and players do take notes.

Screen Shot 2017-11-21 at 4.27.02 AM

Who doesn’t remember when Carey Price‘s wife, Angela, having to deny rampant rumours about her relationship with her husband, and taking onto Instagram to stop the stupid speculations? We touched on this very blog on other examples, which prompted yours truly to depict some of them as Les MisérHABS… Don’t think for a second that when a wife’s player comes out publicly like Angela had to do, it has no effect on players. It certainly does. If they don’t have to deal with those issues elsewhere, they’ll go there instead or at least, it will be an important factor.

And then, there’s the fans… self-proclaimed the most knowledgeable fans in the NHL, Habs’ fans can be relentless to say the least. As an example, just look at the constant bashing Bergevin receives from those who are still hot that he had the audacity to trade away P.K. Subban. Many won’t even acknowledge that Shea Weber is a better player, and certainly better in the dressing room as well. Players notice that as well folks. That’s not knowledge, it’s stubbornness, borderline harassment. For some, it’s more important to try saving face than admit that they were wrong, a terrible quality for people claiming to be fans of THE TEAM.


In Montreal, it’s a fact that players can’t go anywhere without being recognized. As fans, we tend to think that it comes with the territory but players in that situation may find it cool to start, it doesn’t take long before they think otherwise. They can’t take their kids anywhere, they can’t go to the restaurant, movies or any other “normal” activity without having a crowd around them asking for autographs.

Who here doesn’t remember when back in May 2013, Bergevin gave struggling Carey Price his full support after the team’s elimination at the hands of the Ottawa Senators in the first round? The Canadiens’ goaltender was quoted saying that the pressure was getting to him. He said he would no longer even go to a grocery store to avoid grilling from fans over his performances and that he sometimes felt like a “hobbit in a hole.” To which the Habs’ GM jokingly responded: “Maybe I can do his groceries for him.”


And here we go… sensitive topic as always, the language issue in Montreal resurfaces from time to time and this is one of them. A constant but delicate topic, whether it’s for the choice of a coach or GM, the so-called lack of QMJHL players selected by the Habs at the Draft, the language the team captain speaks… Who amongst you have already forgotten the outrage over Randy Cunneyworth‘s appointment as interim coach, replacing Jacques Martin, back in 2011?

Whether we agree with it or not, protests like the one shown above make their turn around the league and NHL players watch that, shake their head and they become contributors in their decision to come play in Montreal or pick a different destination once they reach free agency.

Many players have a wife and kids and when a player becomes a UFA, he is consulting with his spouse and wants to do what’s right for the family. The kids’ education is very important and giving them the option to the best school (in English) is a factor. Granted, some of their beliefs are misconceptions but to them, it’s legitimate. The issue is that often, players won’t take the time to listen to Bergevin and the team, giving them a chance to answer their concerns. That’s a fact, a reality that exists, regardless of if WE think it’s important or not, if it’s legitimate or not. It is to them and ultimately, THEY are the ones making the decision.


Some of the above-mentioned factors are more prominent than others and as we know, some are simply misconceptions. But there is no denying that it takes a special type of character to play in Montreal. If one tends to succumb to pressure, they will rapidly sink in a Habs’ uniform while others thrive under that same pressure.

It seems like the only way to convince players that Montreal isn’t as bad of a place to play hockey as some seem to think, the Canadiens have to trade for them to give them a taste. Jeff Petry, after being acquired at the trade deadline in 2015, has signed a six-year contract extension with the team and he seems to truly enjoy playing in Montreal. Perhaps paying a bigger price at trade deadline to give those key players a taste, would be the way to go? I mean look at what Max Domi has to say about the Habs, their fans and the atmosphere of playing in the biggest pressure-cooker in the NHL:

Which leads me to the final point: the narrative of “it’s the GM’s job to convince free agents to come to Montreal”. There are very few narratives being more far fetched than that. It’s an attempt at simplifying a very complex situation, one that most fans can read right through. It’s mostly being used by people who have an agenda, an axe to grind against the GM, and who will use any means in their arsenal to put him down, to prove their point. They likely don’t even know how ridiculous such statements can be. But we know who they are, right Habs’ fans?

Enjoy the rookie camp, the golf tournament, the main camp and the pre-season games folks as for the first time in a very long time, the Canadiens and their fans have a lot to be excited about. Go Habs Go!